#1
Jeff the killer X reader - A psych...by Ash
☠️♥️When you meet Jeff for the first time when him and his family moved in, you knew something was different about him. It pulled you closer to him, but you had no idea...
#2
sinful ⇢ jeff the killerby ❁
[Y/N]'s life was pretty much normal, yet boring until she's suddenly sucked in to a dark filled world. The world that's terrorized by Jeff the Killer. Having no where to...
#3
Creepypasta Toxic Boyfriend Scenar...by ★cassie
As the title reads, this is you in a toxic relationship with the characters. As this is my first story I'll only be adding 6 of my favorite characters which are Jeff, To...
Completed
#4
More Than a Pretty Face (Jeff x Re...by BrittMyerz1997
Every girl that Jeff the Killer meets and murders hasn't been afraid of him for the past 6 years. All he wants is for someone to be afraid of him, but love him at the sa...
#5
Jeff x Male!Readerby Qing of no plot
(Y/N). Young. Dumb. Legally blind. And that's it.
Oh, and a serial killer thinks he's cute. There's that too.
#6
Fucking Perfect (Jeff the killer x...by
(Y/n) is often bullied at school and abused by her parents when she comes home. Sadly it has happened so many times that she has gotten used to it and no longer resists...
#7
Jeff the killer x readerby worthless
as normal i make it up as i go *shrugs*
TW
blood, violence
Jeff is a psychopath, he will be treated as such. It will be similar to joker and harly quinn sort of (kinda)
Completed
#8
A Kiss To Change It All - Montgome...by Sophia
"He is a jock, for fuck's sake, a jock. Not just a jock but the worse of them all and ... And I fucking liked kissing him."
Originally posted on Tumblr (under...
#9
Jeff the killer X male reader by •chishiyasbae•
The chapters will be short but they will come out quicker
Your 17
You have a mother and a father
You live with your family
#11
Trick your Treat (Creepypasta Vari...by EatYourEgo
I couldn't exactly turn any of these into stories but- I can give you sweet little treats instead! I write these in between my actual stories, if you would, feel free to...
#12
Jeff the killer x Child readerby u_Honey_u
Sequel is out!
There aren't many stories like this, so I decided why not? this story is about a child named Y/N who gets adopted by the creepypastas. (No photos are mine...
#13
To Live without Fear [Jeff the Kil...by Jcreeps
The one thing every living creature has in common is fear. Fear keeps us alive, drives us forward, and makes us still. Jeff the Killer thought he knew everything about f...
#14
Creepypasta Boyfriend Scenariosby A Humor Enthusiast
Read at your own risk!
Contains:
One deranged killer who wears pink boxers.
One little blonde elf.. Midget... Thing.
One extremely Dark and handsome Link.
One monochr...
#16
mutual (Jeff the Killer x Reader) by waluigisspawn
(y/n) was a killer. And she happened to kill Jeffs victims, much to his disapproval.
So naturally, he decides to track down his competitor and kill them, but Slender ha...
#17
𝗬𝗼𝘂𝗿 𝗟𝗼𝗰𝗮𝗹 𝗘𝗺𝗼 (Jeff T...by ☆T⦻BIE☆
Before Jeff's life took a turn for the worst, you were moved to a new school. After a week without making any friends, you befriend a kid named Jeff. Jeff was the quiet...
#18
Twisted Games (Jeff The Killer x F...by MovedAccounts:)
School was almost over. After exams, there were few more weeks of that shithole, and then she would be free. But as the school was called in for a meeting in the main ha...
#19
creepypasta x readerby dreamypup
One day, ( y/n ) decides that she is done with her mother's abuse. She sneaks out of the house during the dead of the night, only to be met with two masked figures and a...
#20
Insanityby Nat Ta Lee
She stayed quiet, hoping that the man wouldn't notice her behind the couch.
She held her breath, knowing that if she let go her cover would be destroyed, obliterated, g...